Cedar Wood Vs. Redwood: Which is Best for My Fence?

Oct 6, 2023 | Fence Ideas, Fence Staining

Embarking on a new fencing project and found yourself at a crossroads – cedar or redwood?

The cedar vs. redwood debate is a common one among homeowners, given that both are renowned for their natural beauty and durability.

But which one will serve your specific needs best?

cedar vs redwood

Our comprehensive guide is designed to help you navigate this decision.

Delve into the unique characteristics, pros, and cons of each wood type.

We provide insights that will enable you to make an informed decision, ensuring your new fence not only enhances your property’s aesthetic appeal but also stands the test of time.

Let’s get ready to unravel the Cedar vs. Redwood enigma!

Understanding the Importance of Wood Selection

Choosing the right type of wood for your fence is such a big deal.

best wood for fencing

Durability and Longevity: 

Different types of wood have varying levels of durability.

Some are naturally resistant to rot and pests, which means they’ll last longer than those that aren’t.

If you’re investing time and money into a fence, you’d want it to stand strong for as long as possible.

Maintenance Needs: 

The type of wood you choose will also determine how much maintenance your fence will require.

Some woods need to be frequently stained or sealed to keep them in good condition, while others require less upkeep.

Aesthetic Appeal: 

Different woods come with unique colors, grains, and textures.

The right wood can enhance the aesthetic appeal of your fence, complementing your home’s exterior and adding to your property’s overall curb appeal.


The cost of wood types varies significantly.

While some woods are more expensive upfront, they might be more cost-effective in the long run due to their durability and lower maintenance needs.

Why Choose Cedar Wood?

Cedar wood is often hailed as one of the best options for fencing due to several reasons:

cedar wood material

Natural Resistance

Cedar, particularly Western Red Cedar, is naturally resistant to decay and pests such as insects.

This is due to the natural oils and acids it contains, making it a robust choice for a fence.


Cedar wood is incredibly durable.

It can withstand harsh weather conditions and still maintain its structural integrity for many years, offering longevity that makes it a cost-effective choice in the long run.

Aesthetic Appeal

With its rich, red-toned hue and straight grain, cedar wood is aesthetically pleasing.

A cedar fence can provide a warm, attractive addition to your property.

Minimal Shrinkage

Unlike some other wood types, cedar doesn’t tend to warp or shrink significantly with changes in weather and humidity.

This means your cedar fence will maintain its shape and structure over time.

Easy Maintenance

While all fences require some maintenance, cedar’s natural resistance to decay and pests reduces the need for frequent or costly upkeep.


Why Choose Redwood?

Redwood is often considered one of the top choices for fencing, and here’s why:

redwood wood material

Striking Beauty

Redwood’s rich, luxurious color and beautiful grain patterns make it a standout choice for aesthetics.

A redwood fence can add a touch of elegance to any property.


Redwood is an incredibly durable wood.

It can resist harsh weather conditions and maintain its structural integrity for many years.

Natural Resistance

Similar to cedar, redwood is naturally resistant to decay and pests due to the tannins it contains.

This makes it a long-lasting choice for fencing.


Redwood is less prone to warping or shrinking compared to other woods.

This means a redwood fence is likely to maintain its shape and appearance despite changes in temperature and humidity.

Low Maintenance

Redwood requires less maintenance than many other types of wood.

Its natural resistance to rot and pests means it doesn’t need as frequent treatment or repair.

Cedar Vs. Redwood: The Verdict

So, Cedar or Redwood?

The choice ultimately depends on your specific needs and circumstances.

cedar vs redwood verdict

Cedar might be a perfect choice if you’re looking for a balance between cost and durability.

However, if budget is less of a constraint and you’re more interested in a unique aesthetic appeal, Redwood could be the winner.

In essence, both cedar and redwood are fantastic choices for fences, each with their unique benefits and drawbacks.

The key is to evaluate what matters the most to you – be it cost, durability, or aesthetic appeal.

Quite an interesting comparison!

Remember, whatever wood you choose, proper installation and maintenance are key to ensuring your fence remains beautiful and serves you well for many years.

Whether you opt for redwood or cedar for your fence, there’s an essential step that shouldn’t be overlooked: staining your fence.

But why is that so crucial?

The Importance of Staining

Staining does more than just enhancing the natural beauty of your fence.

It provides a crucial protective layer that shields the wood from elements like UV rays, moisture, and insects.

applying stain

This can significantly extend the lifespan of your fence, regardless of whether it’s made of cedar or redwood. 

If you are new to it, you must learn the basics on how to stain a fence.

Quite an essential step.


You might be wondering, ‘How do I ensure a quality, even stain without it consuming a lot of my time?’

That’s where StainTrac comes in.

Why StainTrac?

StainTrac is a revolutionary tool that simplifies the staining process.

It’s designed to make the application quicker, easier, and more uniform.

So, what makes StainTrac the best tool for staining your fence?

StainTrac allows for the stain to be applied evenly on all sides of the fence pickets, reducing the chances of missed spots.

It ensures the stain deeply penetrates the wood, offering optimal protection against decay and pests.

Furthermore, using StainTrac reduces the mess often associated with staining, making the clean-up process a breeze.

It also ensures minimal wastage of stain, making your staining project more cost-effective.

So, whether you opt for the rich tones of cedar or the luxurious appeal of redwood for your fence, remember to protect and enhance it with a good stain.

And for a fast, quality staining process, StainTrac is your go-to solution.